Celtic may have celebrated a dramatic 3-2 Europa League victory over Beşiktaş, but behind the scenes, questions about the club’s treatment of its squad players are continuing to grow.
Martin O’Neill’s side desperately needed that European result after a difficult run, yet not everyone at Parkhead has been enjoying the same opportunities to make an impact.
For some players, the situation has become increasingly frustrating, with limited minutes raising serious questions about their futures. And one Celtic midfielder could now be heading towards the exit door when the January transfer window opens.
Luke McCowan is the latest player to find himself at the centre of that uncertainty, with former Aberdeen chief executive Keith Wyness predicting that the midfielder will eventually agree to a temporary move away from Parkhead.
Speaking exclusively to Football Insider, Wyness believes Celtic could sanction a loan deal in January, potentially allowing McCowan to rebuild his reputation and demonstrate his value before the club considers a permanent sale next summer.
The 28-year-old has endured a difficult spell since joining Celtic from Dundee. Having made 42 appearances across all competitions last season, his involvement has fallen dramatically this campaign.
McCowan has reportedly played just 87 minutes of football, a remarkable decline for someone who featured so regularly during his first season at the club.
His situation also comes after he received heavy criticism following Celtic’s Champions League qualifying exit in August, making his struggle to regain a regular place even more difficult.
Wyness believes the midfielder still has enough quality to make an impact elsewhere in Scotland, but questioned whether Celtic are doing enough to support players who find themselves outside the first-choice group.

Speaking on Football Insider’s Inside Track podcast, he said:
“The way I’m looking at that is that your top stars, those situations tend to fix themselves in some way, you know, either the agents are pressing, or the club does something and that gets fixed,” he said.
“It’s the players who are the 15th to 20th players in the squad that you’ve got to look at and how the club treats them. And it’s the values of the club that dictate how those players get treated when there isn’t pressing demand from fans.”
He then specifically identified McCowan as someone whose situation needs addressing.
“McCowan fits into that category as far as I’m concerned. They’ve got to either show that they’re going to back him, and then he’s going to feel that they can go forward.”
However, the former Aberdeen chief executive believes a January loan is the more likely outcome.
“But, I think it will end up being a January loan to try and get some sort of valuation going forward. Loans can work well in Scotland. And I’m sure there is still a talented player in there that needs a chance to go and prove it.”
Wyness also questioned Celtic’s wider approach to squad management, suggesting McCowan is not the only player who has been left frustrated by his circumstances.
“But again, it speaks to what Celtic are doing in terms of values around those squad players that made some big mistakes. With a few of them recently, they’re not treating a lot of the squad well.”
Anthony Ralston was another player mentioned by Wyness, with the defender also finding himself on the fringes despite his long association with the club.
The comments create another uncomfortable situation for O’Neill, who recently suggested that McCowan still had a future at Celtic. However, the midfielder’s lack of playing time has done little to support that reassurance.
And the timing is particularly interesting because Celtic are already facing scrutiny over their managerial situation.
Football Insider separately reported on Friday that O’Neill could be dismissed if Celtic lose their position at the top of the Scottish Premiership. The club’s hierarchy are reportedly concerned about the team’s inconsistency, while Rangers remain just four points behind with a game in hand.
That means the coming weeks could be significant for both the manager and several players whose futures remain uncertain.
For McCowan, January could offer an opportunity to escape his current situation, secure regular football elsewhere and remind Scottish football of the qualities that convinced Celtic to sign him.
But if Wyness’s prediction proves correct, the midfielder’s Parkhead career could be heading towards a temporary ending sooner than many supporters expected.