Willie Collum has admitted that referee Ryan Lee made a mistake during Rangers’ controversial Premier Sports Cup semi-final victory over Aberdeen, with the SFA head of refereeing confirming that James Penrice should have received a yellow card for his dangerous challenge on Afeez Aremu.
The revelation has reopened the debate surrounding Rangers’ progression to the final, particularly because Penrice remained on the pitch after escaping punishment and subsequently played a crucial role in the winning goal.
Derek McInnes’ side eventually secured a 1-0 victory at Hampden, with Ryan Naderi scoring seven minutes from time to book their place in the Premier Sports Cup final.
However, the biggest talking point from the encounter was the incident involving Penrice and Aremu, which occurred midway through the first half.
The Rangers left-back stretched for a ball in midfield but caught the Aberdeen midfielder high on the side and ribs with his studs.
Referee Lee awarded Aberdeen a free-kick but surprisingly decided against showing Penrice a yellow or red card.
VAR official John Beaton reviewed the incident but did not recommend an intervention, allowing the Rangers defender to continue playing.
Aberdeen were understandably frustrated by the decision and subsequently approached the SFA seeking an explanation for why Penrice had escaped punishment.
Now, Collum has provided that explanation, and his assessment confirms that the referee got an important part of the decision wrong.
Speaking on the SFA’s VAR Review show, Collum admitted that the incident initially did not look particularly serious from his position in the VAR centre, but the replays revealed something different.

“I was in the VAR centre watching the game and it looked nothing to me on first view. Then when you see the replays you can obviously see there is more to it.
“The referee is caught side-on so he is almost looking through the Aberdeen player when the contact comes. What it’s certainly not is careless. The referee describes it as careless, but for us this is a reckless challenge.
“There is an issue here in terms of the height of the challenge, but that’s the only criteria for us that’s met.”
Collum’s admission is particularly significant because Lee had classified the challenge as careless, whereas the SFA’s head of refereeing believes it should have been considered reckless.
That distinction matters because a reckless challenge warrants a yellow card, meaning Penrice should not have escaped the incident without a booking.
However, Collum stopped short of agreeing with those who believed the Rangers defender deserved an immediate red card.
Despite acknowledging the dangerous nature of the challenge, he insisted that the incident did not involve the excessive force or brutality required to justify a sending-off.
“Lots of media outlets were showing a still image. If you brought the referee to the monitor with a still image of that you would immediately give a red card. But is there excessive force? Is there brutality? For us there is not.
“There is height, but the contact is not forceful, therefore we think it should have been a yellow card.”
In other words, Collum believes Lee made a refereeing mistake by failing to book Penrice, but he does not believe the challenge met the threshold for a red card.
Penrice went on to help Rangers reach the final
The timing of the incident makes Collum’s admission even more significant for Aberdeen.
Had Penrice received the yellow card he deserved, he would still have been eligible to continue playing, but the Rangers defender would at least have been formally punished for the challenge.
Instead, he escaped without any card and remained involved as McInnes’ side continued their pursuit of a place in the final.
Penrice subsequently played a key role in the decisive goal, with his low driven effort being deflected into the path of Naderi, who finished to give Rangers a 1-0 victory.
That goal ultimately ended Aberdeen’s hopes of reaching the final and sent Rangers through to another domestic cup showpiece.
The controversy has also attracted criticism from former referees, with Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden among those who believed Penrice should have been sent off.
Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett also considered the challenge worthy of a dismissal.
Collum, however, has now made the SFA’s official assessment clear: the challenge was reckless, the correct punishment was a yellow card, but there was insufficient force or brutality to justify a red.
For Aberdeen, the frustration will remain that Penrice escaped without even a booking before going on to contribute to the goal that knocked them out.
For McInnes and Rangers, the result stands, and they have secured their place in the Premier Sports Cup final.
But Collum’s admission has provided fresh confirmation that the officials made a mistake during a crucial moment of the semi-final, with Rangers benefiting from Penrice remaining unpunished.