“I was in the VAR centre watching the game and…” — Scottish FA head of referees Willie Collum speaks on Cheating their way to the Sports Cup final vs Aberdeen after Referee Ryan Lee favoured the Gers

Willie Collum has addressed the controversy surrounding James Penrice’s high-foot challenge on Aberdeen midfielder Afeez Aremu during Rangers’ Premier Sports Cup semi-final victory, admitting that the Rangers defender should have received a yellow card.

The incident attracted considerable attention after Penrice stretched for a ball in midfield and caught Aremu high on the side and ribs with his studs.

Referee Ryan Lee awarded Aberdeen a free-kick but decided against showing a card, describing the challenge as careless rather than reckless.

VAR official John Beaton also reviewed the incident but opted against intervening, allowing Penrice to remain on the pitch.

The decision has now been examined by SFA head of referees Collum, who admitted that the challenge looked considerably worse when viewed through the available replays.

Speaking on the SFA’s VAR Review show, Collum revealed that he initially did not consider the incident particularly serious when watching it live from the VAR centre.

However, after examining the footage, he disagreed with the referee’s classification of the challenge and insisted that it should have been considered reckless.

“I was in the VAR centre watching the game and it looked nothing to me on first view. Then when you see the replays you can obviously see there is more to it.

“The referee is caught side-on so he is almost looking through the Aberdeen player when the contact comes. What it’s certainly not is careless. The referee describes it as careless, but for us this is a reckless challenge.

“There is an issue here in terms of the height of the challenge, but that’s the only criteria for us that’s met.”

Despite acknowledging that the challenge was reckless, Collum stopped short of suggesting that Penrice should have been sent off.

He explained that although the height of the contact was a significant concern, the challenge did not involve the excessive force or brutality required to justify a red card.

Collum also addressed the still images that circulated across various media outlets, explaining why looking at a single photograph could give a misleading impression of the incident.

“Lots of media outlets were showing a still image. If you brought the referee to the monitor with a still image of that you would immediately give a red card. But is there excessive force? Is there brutality? For us there is not.

“There is height, but the contact is not forceful, therefore we think it should have been a yellow card.”

The SFA’s position is therefore that Penrice was fortunate not to receive a booking, but that the challenge did not meet the threshold for a sending-off.

The incident also raises questions about the original on-field assessment, with Collum admitting that referee Ryan Lee was not ideally positioned to see the full extent of the contact.

Nevertheless, VAR did not intervene, and Penrice remained on the pitch.

The Rangers left-back subsequently played a part in the decisive moment of the match, helping set up Ryan Naderi’s winning goal against Aberdeen.

That makes the incident particularly significant, given that a yellow card would have changed the disciplinary outcome but would not have resulted in Penrice’s dismissal.

Ultimately, Collum has now clarified the SFA’s assessment: the challenge was reckless, a yellow card should have been shown, but there was not enough excessive force or brutality to warrant a red card.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like