Chris Sutton’s furious criticism of James Penrice has suffered a fresh setback after former Premier League referee Keith Hackett delivered his verdict on the controversial penalty awarded to Rangers during their 2-0 victory over St Mirren.
The Rangers defender was at the centre of one of the biggest talking points from Saturday’s Scottish Premiership encounter in Paisley after going down inside the penalty area following contact from St Mirren midfielder Samuel Ramos.
With the game still goalless and less than 20 minutes played, referee Nick Walsh pointed to the spot after assessing the incident, with VAR subsequently checking the decision without recommending that he overturn it.
Ryan Naderi stepped forward and converted the penalty, scoring his ninth goal of the season in all competitions to give Derek McInnes’ side a crucial breakthrough.
Dan Neil then added a second shortly after the hour mark to secure all three points for the visitors.
However, the penalty decision attracted considerable criticism, particularly from Celtic legend Sutton, who believed Penrice had made the most of minimal contact to win his team a spot-kick.
Speaking on Sky Sports, Sutton accused the Rangers defender of playing the referee like a piccolo.

He said:
“I think we all agree that it was the wrong decision. There has to be sufficient contact. James Penrice has played Nick Walsh like a piccolo.
“Ramos is steaming back but how much contact is there if any? It’s absolutely minimal. Let’s not hide behind a clear and obvious error. That’s absolutely not a penalty.”
James McFadden also questioned the decision, describing it as an extremely soft penalty and insisting that the available replays did not convince him there had been sufficient contact.
But former referee Keith Hackett has now offered a different interpretation, insisting that the amount of contact was not the deciding factor when assessing whether a foul had occurred.
Speaking exclusively to Ibrox News, Hackett explained why he believed Walsh was right to award Rangers the penalty.
He said:
“It’s a careless challenge by the defender, who makes contact with his opponent,” Hackett said. “It’s a foul and a penalty kick.
“The law defines ‘careless’ as when a player shows a lack of attention or consideration when making a challenge or acts without precaution.”
Hackett’s explanation directly challenges the argument that Penrice went down too easily or that the contact was too minimal to justify a penalty.
Rather than focusing on how much contact Ramos made, the former referee believes the important consideration was whether the St Mirren midfielder had challenged his opponent carelessly.
And according to Hackett, the answer was yes.
His intervention will provide encouragement for Rangers supporters who felt their team deserved the penalty, particularly after Sutton’s comments appeared to suggest Penrice had deceived the match officials.
Interestingly, Rangers favourite Kris Boyd also offered a more balanced assessment of the incident during Sky Sports’ coverage.
Boyd admitted he was not entirely convinced that the contact was enough to warrant a spot-kick, although he understood why Walsh had made the decision.
He said:
“I don’t think there is much in it but I can see why it’s been given.
“There is no doubt it’s a lazy challenge. Does he potentially stand on his foot yet? Is there potential for a touch on the thigh yes? For me I’m not sure it’s enough but we can’t criticise referees for not making decisions.”
Boyd’s comments were particularly notable because he did not automatically defend Rangers despite his strong connection to the club.
Penrice himself also defended his actions during his post-match interview, explaining that he felt Ramos make contact and insisted that the challenge prevented him from reaching the ball.
He said:
“I’m getting told it is a penalty and it isn’t a penalty but I felt the contact, though I haven’t seen it back.”
He added:
“In terms of (feeling the contact and going down), I, I couldn’t get there, he’s kicked us (me), I couldn’t get the ball, so yeah”
The Rangers defender therefore maintained that he had genuinely felt the contact, although he admitted he had not watched the incident back himself.
With Hackett now backing Walsh’s decision and explaining how a careless challenge can constitute a foul regardless of the amount of contact, the controversy has taken another interesting turn.
Sutton remains firmly opposed to the decision, but the former referee’s intervention offers a clear explanation for why the penalty was awarded.
For Rangers, the most important thing was that Naderi converted from the spot and Neil later made sure of the result.
The 2-0 victory gives McInnes’ men another important three points, while the debate surrounding Penrice’s penalty continues long after the final whistle.