The controversial decision that allowed Leeds United defender Jayden Bogle to escape a red card against Tottenham Hotspur has sparked widespread debate, particularly after Mathys Tel was forced off injured following the challenge.
Leeds secured a valuable 1-0 victory at Elland Road on Saturday, November 7, but the result was overshadowed by a contentious incident in the first half that left Tottenham furious with the officiating.
Bogle caught Tel on the Achilles with a challenge from behind in the 34th minute. Referee John Brooks immediately awarded a free-kick but decided against showing a card, leaving Spurs players and supporters questioning how the defender had avoided further punishment.
The incident was subsequently reviewed by VAR official Tony Harrington, with the check lasting several minutes. However, despite the dangerous nature of the contact, the original decision was upheld.
Now, the explanation behind the controversial call has emerged, with the communication between the officials revealing precisely why Bogle was not sent off.
During the VAR review, Harrington explained:
“I’m confirming the on-field decision of no red card. There’s a lack of speed going into the challenge and he’s stepping into the tackle. Confirming a reckless challenge”.
That statement provides the clearest indication of how the officials reached their conclusion.
Although VAR acknowledged that Bogle’s challenge was reckless, the officials apparently did not believe it met the threshold for serious foul play that would have justified a straight red card.
The assessment focused particularly on the speed of the challenge and the defender’s movement into the tackle.
In other words, the officials recognised that Bogle had committed a reckless challenge but decided that the nature of his approach did not warrant the most severe punishment.
However, that explanation has done little to calm the controversy.
Tel was caught directly around the Achilles area and initially attempted to continue playing before being substituted in the 43rd minute.
Tottenham manager Roberto De Zerbi subsequently described the situation as a bad injury, explaining that further medical checks would be needed before the club could establish the full extent of the problem.
The incident also attracted strong criticism from former Premier League referee Mike Dean.
Dean believed Bogle should have been dismissed, drawing comparisons with Jean-Philippe Mateta’s red card against the defender’s challenge the previous week.
He said:
“Mateta’s was red last week, and he’s (Bogle) gone in, the ball’s nowhere near and he’s caught him (Tel) with his left foot right on the back of the Achilles,”
“It has to be (a red card). I think where he’s caught him, the ball’s gone, I mean it’s just right on the back of the Achilles. I just think it’s a red card.”
Dean also questioned the consistency of the decisions being made by officials, arguing that Bogle’s challenge deserved the same punishment.
Steven Gerrard also expressed his disappointment with the handling of the incident, insisting that the referee should have been instructed to examine the footage on the pitchside monitor.
The former Liverpool captain believed the contact was dangerous and could have resulted in a different outcome had Brooks been given the opportunity to review it himself.
Tottenham are now preparing to submit a formal complaint to Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) over the decision.
The complaint underlines the club’s dissatisfaction with the way the incident was handled, especially given the potential consequences for Tel.
Meanwhile, Leeds manager Daniel Farke defended his player after the match, saying he had not watched the incident back and insisting that Bogle was not someone who deliberately set out to hurt opponents.
Farke also described his defender as the softest player in the squad, while expressing sympathy for Tel and wishing him a speedy recovery.
Nevertheless, the controversy has continued to overshadow Leeds’ victory.
Noah Okafor scored the decisive goal in the 79th minute after coming off the bench, giving Leeds a 1-0 win and ending their five-match winless run.
But with Tottenham preparing their formal complaint, Mike Dean and Gerrard questioning the decision, and Tel facing further medical assessment, the incident involving Bogle is likely to remain one of the biggest talking points from the weekend.
For the officials, the explanation is that the challenge was reckless but did not meet the threshold for a red card. For Tottenham, that reasoning is far from convincing.