Rangers may have walked away from Paisley with a crucial victory, but the controversial penalty that helped them break the deadlock has left even one of their most recognisable former players questioning the decision.
Kris Boyd, a Rangers favourite who knows exactly what it means to represent the Ibrox club, was on Sky Sports punditry duty when James Penrice went down inside the St Mirren penalty area.
The incident happened with less than 20 minutes played, as AEK Athens loanee Penrice attempted to get past St Mirren midfielder Samuel Ramos.
Ramos came across to challenge the Rangers defender, who went to ground and appealed for a foul. Referee Nick Walsh eventually pointed to the spot following a VAR review, giving the visitors an opportunity to take the lead.
Ryan Naderi stepped forward and converted the penalty, registering his ninth goal of the season in all competitions.
But while the Rangers players celebrated, the decision quickly became a major talking point, with questions being raised about whether there had been enough contact to justify awarding a spot-kick.
And Boyd’s reaction was particularly interesting because he did not simply defend the decision because it benefited his former club.
Speaking on Sky Sports, the ex-Rangers striker admitted that there was very little between the players and suggested the penalty might not have been justified.

Boyd said:
“I don’t think there is much in it but I can see why it’s been given.
“There is no doubt it’s a lazy challenge. Does he potentially stand on his foot yet? Is there potential for a touch on the thigh yes? For me I’m not sure it’s enough but we can’t criticise referees for not making decisions.”
Those comments represented a significant admission from someone who has regularly defended Rangers and understands the importance of results in the club’s pursuit of success.
Boyd acknowledged that Ramos had made a careless challenge and could potentially have made contact with Penrice’s foot or thigh.
However, he was equally clear that he was not convinced the contact was sufficient to warrant a penalty.
His assessment also highlighted the difficulty facing match officials when incidents are reviewed from different angles. While Walsh ultimately decided that the contact justified a spot-kick, Boyd questioned whether the available evidence was enough.
The former Rangers forward’s comments are particularly interesting because he did not accuse the officials of deliberately helping his beloved club. Instead, he recognised that the decision was questionable while acknowledging why the referee might have made it.
Nevertheless, his admission gives those questioning the penalty another talking point, especially with the decision having a direct impact on the scoreline.
Boyd also found himself taking a different position from Celtic hero Chris Sutton, who was much more forceful in his criticism of the award.
Sutton accused Penrice of playing Walsh “like a piccolo” and insisted there was nowhere near enough contact for a penalty.
James McFadden, who was co-commentating on the match, also questioned the decision, saying he could not establish how much contact had actually taken place.
But it was Boyd’s comments that carried a different significance for Rangers supporters.
Rather than dismissing the criticism or automatically backing the officials, the former Ibrox striker admitted that he was unsure whether the challenge deserved to be punished with a penalty.
The decision ultimately allowed Naderi to break the deadlock, putting Rangers in front after Walsh’s intervention following the VAR review.
And although Boyd stopped short of describing the award as cheating, his assessment was a clear acknowledgement that Rangers benefited from a decision he was not entirely convinced by.
For a former Rangers favourite, that was an uncomfortable verdict on a major moment in his old club’s victory at St Mirren.