Celtic produced one of their most dramatic European nights in recent times on Thursday, fighting back from behind to defeat Beşiktaş 3-2 at Celtic Park.
Martin O’Neill’s side had endured a miserable start to their Europa League campaign, losing their opening three matches, and desperately needed a response in front of their home supporters.
However, after a disappointing first half, the Hoops found themselves trailing when Junior Olaitan opened the scoring in the 54th minute, converting the rebound after Sam Johnstone had saved his penalty.
The situation looked increasingly uncomfortable for O’Neill until his second-half changes completely transformed the contest.
Callum Osmand came off the bench and equalised with his very first touch before turning provider for Camilo Durán, who put Celtic ahead. Although Beşiktaş captain Orkun Kökçü restored parity in the 86th minute, Durán struck again almost immediately to deliver a sensational 3-2 victory.
But while Celtic supporters were celebrating a crucial European result, Beşiktaş manager Vincenzo Italiano was left furious with his players.
And the Italian coach has now made a remarkable accusation about how his team surrendered the points in Glasgow.
Rather than simply accepting that Celtic had produced an excellent comeback, Italiano believes Beşiktaş effectively gifted their opponents all three goals through avoidable defensive mistakes.
Speaking after the match, the manager did not hide his frustration with his team’s inability to protect their advantage.
In comments published on Beşiktaş’s official website, he said:
“I’m extremely disappointed tonight. We need to find a solution for our defense. We have been conceding too many chances and making too mistakes lately. We’ve thrown away three points that were within our reach. We need to be as tough and focused as we used to be.”
That was not the end of his criticism.
According to Turkish news agency DHA, Italiano also accused his players of gifting Celtic all three goals during his post-match press conference, describing the defensive mistakes as avoidable.
The Beşiktaş boss was particularly unhappy with the manner in which his side conceded the decisive goal.
Having fought back to make it 2-2 through Kökçü in the 86th minute, the visitors had given themselves an opportunity to leave Glasgow with a valuable point.
Instead, Celtic attacked again almost immediately, with Durán finding the net to complete his brace and send Parkhead into celebration.
Italiano felt his players should have stopped the attack before the Colombian was allowed to get into a dangerous scoring position.
For the Beşiktaş manager, it was another example of his team’s defensive shortcomings costing them dearly.
However, his assessment also overlooks the considerable impact Celtic’s substitutions had on the match.
O’Neill introduced Osmand, Durán and Colby Donovan in the 61st minute, with Celtic still trailing 1-0. The changes injected fresh energy into the Hoops’ attack, and Osmand immediately demonstrated why the manager had turned to him.
The young forward found the bottom corner with his first touch after collecting Callum McGregor’s pass, giving Celtic the equaliser they desperately needed.
He then produced the assist for Durán’s first goal, with the Colombian showing composure to round Alexander Nübel before finishing.
Durán’s winner was equally important, as he reacted quickly inside the penalty area after Kieran Tierney’s delivery reached him, finding a way to beat the Beşiktaş goalkeeper once again.
It was a remarkable turnaround, particularly considering Celtic had failed to register a shot on target during the first half.
O’Neill subsequently defended his substitutions, insisting they had been planned rather than desperate changes made in response to the scoreline. He also pointed towards the demanding fixture schedule as a reason for giving certain players a rest.
For Beşiktaş, however, the defeat will be difficult to swallow.
Italiano’s side had entered the match unbeaten in their opening three Europa League fixtures and looked capable of extending that run before Celtic’s substitutes changed everything.
The result leaves Celtic with three points from four league-phase matches, keeping their hopes of progressing in the competition alive.
And while Italiano believes his players handed Celtic the victory, O’Neill and his substitutes will know that taking advantage of those defensive weaknesses required quality, determination and ruthless finishing.
Celtic got all three when it mattered most.