The Scottish FA have released the official VAR audio from Celtic’s dramatic 3-1 victory over Motherwell, shedding new light on the penalty decision that proved pivotal in the Scottish Premiership clash.
The audio captures the moment when VAR official Kevin Clancy called referee John Beaton over to review the incident involving Daizen Maeda in the second half. Maeda had been fouled by Motherwell defender Emmanuel Longelo at the back post, an event that was initially missed by Beaton, who had awarded a goal kick.
Listeners can hear the deliberation unfold as Clancy directs Beaton to the pitchside monitor to take a second look at the challenge. The replay clearly shows Longelo wrapping his arms around Maeda, denying him a clear goalscoring opportunity — a textbook penalty situation.
After reviewing the footage, Beaton correctly overturned his initial decision, awarding Celtic the penalty and issuing a straight red card to Longelo. Tomas Cvancara calmly converted from 12 yards, putting the Hoops ahead and leaving Motherwell to play the remainder of the match with ten men.
The audio provides unprecedented insight into how VAR officials communicate during high-pressure decisions. It shows the precise language used, the thought process behind sending the referee to the monitor, and the confirmation once the decision was finalized.
Celtic went on to secure a 3-1 win, with Yang Hyun-jun adding two more goals, but it was the Maeda incident that ultimately shifted the game in their favour. The release of the VAR audio has reignited debate among fans and pundits alike about consistency in officiating and the impact of video technology on Scottish football.
While some supporters argue that the review demonstrates VAR working correctly, others continue to question why certain incidents — like Maeda’s own accidental collision earlier in the game — weren’t flagged. Regardless, the audio offers a rare behind-the-scenes look at the decision-making that can change the outcome of a title race match.